On May 23, 2024, Gurbir Grewal, the Director of the Division of Enforcement at the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC), delivered a critical address at the Securities Enforcement Forum West 2024. The speech, “The Five Principles of Effective Cooperation in SEC Investigations,” underscored the pivotal role of cooperation between the SEC and the entities under scrutiny. Grewal’s remarks highlighted how adherence to these principles can facilitate more effective enforcement actions and foster a culture of compliance within the financial industry. Arootah Advisor Michele McGurk delves into crucial themes and takeaways for investment managers to integrate into their compliance strategies.
Get the latest news and leadership insights for hedge fund and family office professionals. Sign up for The Capital Return newsletter today.
By providing your email address, you agree to receive email communication from ArootahKey Highlights from the SEC Enforcement Speech
Gurbir Grewal’s speech covered five essential principles for effective cooperation with the SEC: timeliness, completeness, credibility, remediation, and cooperation credit. These principles provide entities with a framework to ensure compliance and foster a cooperative relationship with regulatory bodies.
Timeliness
Grewal began by emphasizing the critical role of timely cooperation in SEC investigations, citing examples from recent enforcement actions to illustrate the standards expected by the SEC. Timeliness not only aids the SEC in swiftly addressing violations but also reflects positively on the entity’s commitment to regulatory compliance. Alternatively, delays can exacerbate the situation, leading to more severe consequences.
Timely self-policing enables earlier issue detection and self-reporting, emphasizing the need for a strong compliance culture led by top management. Additionally, staying current with new regulations and technological advances is crucial to ensure compliance policies remain adequate and relevant. For instance, in the SEC’s case against Cloopen, the company demonstrated the importance of timely cooperation by quickly self-reporting accounting errors to the SEC, which their external auditor discovered. Cloopen’s cooperation included providing detailed explanations, translating key documents, and implementing remedial measures such as forming an independent special committee, terminating involved senior managers, and strengthening internal controls. This proactive approach significantly advanced the investigation’s efficiency and mitigated potential enforcement actions.
Completeness
The completeness of information provided to the SEC is another cornerstone of practical cooperation. Grewal stressed that partial or selective disclosure can hinder the investigative process and damage the credibility of the cooperating entity. Entities are encouraged to be thorough and transparent in their disclosures, ensuring that all relevant facts and documents are presented to the SEC. This level of completeness facilitates a more accurate assessment and resolution of the issues at hand.
An example of successful completeness was highlighted by the SEC enforcement action against Parella Weinberg Partners, in which the SEC considered their self-reporting, cooperation, and remediation efforts. Perella’s internal investigation identified off-channel communications, which they promptly reported to the SEC. They initiated remediation efforts in August 2019, issuing firm devices to all employees, enhancing surveillance with new technologies, and conducting training sessions emphasizing recordkeeping compliance. Additionally, Perella proactively preserved off-channel communications. These actions helped mitigate the enforcement actions against them.
Credibility
According to Grewal, credibility is built on honesty and integrity in all dealings with the SEC. Entities must demonstrate a genuine commitment to uncovering and rectifying misconduct. This involves initial disclosure and ongoing cooperation throughout the investigation. Grewal highlighted that when a possible violation is discovered, it’s crucial to self-report promptly, even if all the facts aren’t yet known.
When an entity calls to report a potential issue and commits to investigating it further, it signifies competent self-policing and a proactive compliance culture. It helps build credibility with SEC staff for future interactions. Conversely, credibility can be significantly undermined by attempts to mislead the SEC or minimize the severity of the misconduct. Entities that maintain high standards of credibility are more likely to receive favorable consideration when resolving their cases.
Remediation
Productive remediation efforts are crucial in demonstrating a commitment to preventing future violations. Grewal pointed out that remediation should be proactive, timely, and meaningful, addressing the misconduct and preventing its recurrence. Entities should take steps to address the root causes of the misconduct, implement robust compliance programs, and ensure that similar issues do not recur. Key measures include disciplining responsible parties, enhancing internal controls, conducting relevant training, hiring experts, clawing back executive compensation, and repaying harmed investors.
Even if you didn’t self-report initially, undertaking comprehensive internal investigations, remediating violations, and improving compliance functions can still earn cooperation credit. The SEC views comprehensive remediation efforts as a strong indicator of an entity’s commitment to compliance and cooperation.
Cooperation Credit
The final principle discussed was the concept of cooperation credit. Grewal explained that the SEC will consider substantial cooperation as a mitigating factor when determining sanctions and penalties. Entities demonstrating exceptional cooperation and collaboration with the SEC can benefit from reduced fines and other enforcement actions. This cooperation credit incentivizes entities to engage fully and transparently with the SEC, ultimately leading to more efficient and impactful enforcement outcomes.
Establishing good communication with the SEC from the outset, whether after a self-report or an SEC inquiry, is crucial. Potent communication allows for timely discussions about arising issues, ensures transparency regarding document environments and processes, and demonstrates cooperation. High-quality, fact-based communication can simplify issues, enhance efficiency, and build credibility with the SEC staff. This proactive approach helps in assessing the reasonableness of responses and reinforces the party’s commitment to compliance.
Grewal’s speech at the Securities Enforcement Forum West 2024 provided valuable insights into the SEC’s expectations for cooperation during investigations. The five principles—timeliness, completeness, credibility, remediation, and cooperation credit—form the foundation of productive cooperation and can significantly influence the outcome of SEC investigations. By adhering to these principles, entities can mitigate potential penalties and contribute to a more transparent and compliant financial market.
Key Takeaways for Investment Managers
Investment managers should take several key takeaways from Grewal’s speech to prepare for their regulatory examinations:
1. Ensure that any potential issues are reported to the SEC as soon as they are identified. Timely responses to SEC inquiries and requests can favorably impact the investigation’s outcome.
2. Provide comprehensive and accurate information to the SEC. Partial disclosures can lead to distrust and complicate the investigative process, while complete disclosures build trust and streamline investigative processes, avoiding delays and misunderstandings.
3. Uphold high honesty and integrity standards in all SEC interactions. Building and maintaining credibility can positively influence the SEC’s assessment of the entity, and transparent dealings foster a positive regulatory relationship.
4. Proactively address any identified issues and implement measures to prevent future occurrences. Proactive remediation demonstrates a commitment to compliance and reduces future regulatory risks.
5. Understand that the SEC values substantial cooperation and may offer reduced penalties in recognition of exceptional cooperation. Engage fully with the SEC to potentially receive cooperation benefits, such as reduced penalties. Demonstrating substantial cooperation underscores commitment to regulatory compliance.
The Bottom Line
By integrating these principles into their compliance strategies, investment managers can better navigate regulatory examinations and contribute to a more transparent and ethical financial environment. Our team of experts can help ensure your compliance. Take the first step and discover how Arootah’s Hedge Fund Advisory can support you.
Get the latest news and leadership insights for hedge fund and family office professionals. Sign up for The Capital Return newsletter today.
By providing your email address, you agree to receive email communication from Arootah